Schnabel: ECB must stay flexible as debt and market shifts reshape policy
ECB Executive Board member Isabel Schnabel said central banks should avoid rigid policy commitments and watch how shocks affect the inflation outlook rather than their source, as rising public debt and non-bank finance change how monetary policy is transmitted.

Speaking at the ECB Conference on Money Markets in Frankfurt, Schnabel reviewed the lessons of the past seven years, a period that took the euro area from persistently low inflation to the fastest tightening cycle in the European Central Bank’s (ECB) history. She said the experience showed policymakers should not become too attached to any single view of the economy, since neither the post-pandemic inflation surge nor the subsequent overlapping shocks from Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the conflict in the Middle East could have been easily foreseen.
She argued forward guidance used during the pandemic had tied the ECB too closely to assumptions of persistently low inflation, and that instruments which are hard to reverse, such as large-scale asset purchases, effectively act as a form of commitment. Policy rates, by contrast, can be adjusted swiftly meeting by meeting, which is why the ECB treats them as its primary instrument.
Schnabel added that the appropriate response to any shock depends on its projected impact on inflation rather than whether it originates from demand or supply. She noted the Transmission Protection Instrument exists to address disorderly market dynamics without expanding the ECB’s broader asset holdings.
On fiscal and financial risks, Schnabel warned that rising public debt and the growing role of non-bank financial intermediaries, including hedge funds that now hold an increasing share of sovereign bonds often financed through repos, could threaten monetary dominance if left unaddressed. She cited International Monetary Fund (IMF) projections showing US government debt rising to 145% of GDP by 2031 from 124% last year, and Chinese government debt rising to 122% from 99% over the same period. She said these shifts mean monetary policy is now transmitted to markets more rapidly than before.
For markets, Schnabel’s remarks on flexible policy instruments and rising sovereign debt matter for euro-area rate expectations, Bunds and the euro, as they signal how the ECB may balance inflation risks against fiscal and financial-stability pressures going forward.
Source: ECB